9 years of
Experience
Imposter syndrome is a pattern of thinking in which a person consistently doubts their abilities and believes they got lucky with their accomplishments and that it was because someone else didn’t realize how incompetent they were. Despite evidence showing the individual has completed tasks or projects, they continue to doubt themselves.
People in professions that include high levels of public recognition, including law, medicine, academia, business, and arts, may experience imposter syndrome more often.
Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes coined the term “imposter syndrome” in 1978. They recognized that many highly successful people had an internalized fear of being found out as fake even though there was evidence of their successes. It is a unique culmination of cognitions and emotions (certain ways of processing information about one’s own success) that does not match the evidence provided.
There are several behaviours that maintain the person’s role. The fear of being identified as fake intensifies hard work and diligence, which can often lead to more praise from others, increasing the sense of ‘feeling good’ and keeping the behavior going. Intellectual inauthenticity can also be observed. Individuals may withhold their original ideas and opinions due to the fear of being rejected, and they never test how their ideas would have been received by others, and hence continue to respond how they assume others may expect them to.
Additionally, people may also use charms and one’s perspective to win approval. They maintain hope that someone (probably an admired authority figure) will realise how special they are and will help them believe in their own ability. This often also fails because despite the praise of the authority figure, they may often assume that the praise is due to their charms presented and not their competence. The approval is not able to reach the underlying belief of “I am stupid” or “I am not really capable”.
There are several reasons why individuals exhibit Imposter Syndrome. In terms of historical clinical observations, two common types of family dynamics appear to contribute to the development of this pattern:
When a sibling is labeled as "the smart one" by parents or other relatives, the individual may compensate for perceived inferiority by working harder than necessary, never developing a belief that they possess adequate competency.
Achievements are consistently praised regardless of whether the achievement meets certain standards. Because the individual has no reference point for measuring their abilities, they fail to establish an internally referenced standard for evaluating their competence.
These family dynamics contribute to an overall attributional bias common among those suffering from Imposter Syndrome. Those exhibiting this pattern tend to attribute success to external factors or events and failures to internal or stable factors like lack of ability. As such, it is impossible for these individuals to develop confidence in their competence over time because positive experiences are continually discredited while negative experiences are seen as confirming their internal beliefs.
Structural and environmental variables also exacerbate this bias. For example, the first in their family to go to college; women in fields dominated by men; members of ethnic groups underrepresented in institutions; etc., may have an additional layer of difficulty establishing a sense of belonging, as their differences may be signaled by actual structural barriers rather than simply by cognitive distortions. Moreover, this pattern tends to increase during times of transition (promotion, graduation from school, entering into a new career), during which time the individual's internal self-image has not adapted to fit their new external position.
Imposter Syndrome has multiple psychological and behavioral consequences:
Increased anxiety/hypervigilance during evaluation situations (e.g., performance evaluations, tests, giving a presentation).
Compensatory burnout resulting from excessive preparation before taking a test or presenting to help alleviate anxiety regarding impending failure.
Refusal to take advantage of opportunities (promotions, publishing articles, leadership positions) based upon competence level.
Decreased ability to utilize feedback (whether positive or negative) since all forms of feedback are viewed through the same lens of distorted interpretation.
Strain caused by interpersonal interactions (in professional/personal relationships) due to excessive effort/work or self-denigrating behaviors becoming habitual.
Despite achieving success in life tasks, feeling like a fraud or fake individual can often be distressing. Individuals can be supported through it in the following ways:
Identifying the pattern: When one explicitly labels their experiences (i.e., "this is imposter syndrome - I am not incompetent"), one creates some cognitive distance between the emotional response and the factual evidence.
Documenting evidence: By keeping records of one’s achievements and receiving feedback, one will be able to counteract the tendency of this pattern to have a selective memory - only remembering disconfirming information.
Cognitive restructuring: One of the most central aspects of cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) is to teach people how to distinguish their subjective emotional responses from objective evidence; to identify the automatic thoughts that lead to these feelings (for example, "the reason they chose me for this position is that they felt sorry for me"); to evaluate whether there is evidence for or against those thoughts; and to construct more realistic alternatives to those thoughts.
Peer consultation: The pattern reinforces itself through the lack of awareness amongst colleagues regarding the extent to which everyone else may also be experiencing the same thing. Through structured peer contexts (such as supervision, peer groups, mentoring, etc.), many people discover that many of their colleagues are also experiencing this phenomenon.
Clinical intervention: Where the pattern has resulted in burnout, avoidance, or depression, clinical intervention is often preferable to self-directed interventions. Psychodynamic therapy can help individuals understand the roots of their experiences, while CBT can help them challenge the beliefs and thinking patterns that contribute to these experiences.
While coping mechanisms may help manage the symptoms of imposter syndrome, lasting change requires developing a stronger sense of self-concept, which can be supported through the following:
Value-based identity vs outcome-based identity: While having a self-concept based on value-based identity (Eg., "I uphold my professional integrity and continually improve my competence") is less susceptible to being derailed than an identity based on performance-related goals (Eg., "I succeeded"), the latter type of identity is more dependent upon factors outside of the person's control.
Self-compassion: Many individuals with imposter syndrome treat other people with less stringent standards than they treat themselves. Developing a greater capacity for self-compassion - that is, accepting that mistakes occur when we are learning and that there is nothing wrong with taking time to become competent - is an important aspect of helping individuals overcome imposter syndrome.
Acceptance of novice status: An individual with a stable identity can accept their own noviceship in areas of knowledge or skill without interpreting this as evidence that they are fraudulent. Competency does not require being evenly distributed across all areas at all times.
Reduced dependence upon external validation: It is possible to reduce the degree to which one relies on external validation for assessing oneself without eliminating the use of feedback.
Imposter Syndrome is not defined as a clinical diagnosis, yet people experience it in real life, and it is common. It is not a flaw, and certain doubts about oneself can be saved from turning into a verdict against one’s worth. One must talk to someone they trust and reach out for professional help.