6 years of
Experience
A lot of companies talk about things like performance, productivity, innovation, and teamwork. Companies spend money on all sorts of things such as technology, training, infrastructure, etc. However, there is something very important that determines how well people perform at work and this is usually ignored. That thing is called "psychological safety."
When someone feels comfortable enough to discuss their feelings (or ideas) in the work place without fear of retaliation (either personally or professionally), then the person has psychological safety.
Think of a typical day at work. An employee finds a problem with a project they were working on; however the employee hesitates to bring up the issue. A junior employee has a differing opinion regarding a senior's decision; therefore, the junior employee remains quiet. An employee is overwhelmed with their workload and fears being seen as incompetent if they ask for assistance. Another employee thinks of an innovative way to make an already existing process run smoother; however, rather than speaking up, the employee believes it would be easier to just keep quiet.
Again, none of the examples I provided illustrate an obvious example of bullying, harassment, or discriminatory behaviour. What the examples do demonstrate is a company culture that creates a sense of uneasiness. When people begin to feel uneasy about expressing themselves openly in the workplace; organisations miss-out on so much more than just hearing what individuals think.
Amy Edmondson defines psychological safety as a collective understanding that team members can share thoughts and experiences, including uncertainty, mistakes and dissenting views, without fear of judgment, rejection, or negative repercussions. Edmondson's definition of psychological safety specifically deals with intra-team risks.
In its simplest form, psychological safety means being able to say:
"I don't understand."
"I believe we might be doing something wrong."
"I need help."
"My view differs."
"I made a mistake."
and know those statements won't lead to ridicule, anger or harm to your reputation.
Psychologically safe workplaces don't necessarily require everyone to agree. Psychologically safe workplaces aren't about avoiding uncomfortable discussions or ignoring poor performance or removing accountability. In many cases, psychologically safe workplaces are actually better equipped to address uncomfortable topics because employees don't have to worry about defending themselves against every disagreement.
Psychologically safe workplaces don't eliminate disagreements. They simply remove fear from discussing disagreements.
Every organisation will make mistakes. What matters is whether those errors are recognised, reported, and remedied.
However, when workers are afraid to speak up due to fear of ridicule or blame, many Mistakes go unreported; concerns stay unvoiced; and opportunities for early corrections is lost.
Healthcare, aviation, manufacturing, and all organisations where failure in communication could result in severe consequences will find this especially significant.
A culture that fears to punish even small errors without considering the context may inadvertently promote a climate of silence where workers will conceal problems.
A culture that encourages accountability can still create an atmosphere of psychological safety so that human error, system failures, neglect and intentional acts of misconduct can be distinguished.
Fear should not suppress a worker from reporting an issue.
Workers are often encouraged to "think outside the box." Yet, when the mere act of asking why we do things this way is seen as questioning authority, innovation becomes much harder. New ideas often start as uncomfortable questions. Why are we doing things this way? Can we do it another way? What if our assumptions are wrong?
Workers who fear adverse reaction will rarely offer unusual ideas or challenge routine methods. Over time, organisations become efficient in repeatedly practicing previous methods while they lose their potential to grow and adapt.
Psychological safety provides room for curiosity, trial and error and productive disagreement.
More than just encouraging creativity is needed for innovation. It needs to be made safe to be creative.
While individual-based approaches to improve mental health in the workplace (e.g., stress management workshops, counseling services, etc.) provide some benefits, they cannot compensate for a work environment characterised by constant fear of intimidation, humiliation or retaliation against voicing concerns.
Regardless of an employee's exceptional coping abilities, working within a hostile and unpredictable work environment with an unstable leader or multiple coworkers who exhibit interpersonal aggression can severely impact their mental health.
Psychological safety reduces unnecessary tension created by unpredictability and can allow workers to communicate openly and predictably about their workload concerns and clarify issues before they develop into larger problems.
Improving mental well-being at work is not simply the worker's responsibility. Organisations need to review the environment they foster.
Having a group of highly skilled people does not automatically produce an effective team.
To form an effective team, you need communication, mutual respect, coordination and recognition of each person's limitations.
When workers feel psychologically safe they are more inclined to share information, ask for help and apply their expertise.
Project Aristotle conducted by Google analysed attributes of successful teams and found that psychological safety was a major attribute of success among them.
The general take-away applies beyond Google: individual capability has merit, yet the environment influences how individual capabilities are used. An exceptionally competent worker who feels intimidated enough to remain silent cannot contribute to full capacity.
Many leaders claim to be available to receive input from workers. However, workers may perceive otherwise. Leaders' intentions do not always equate to the degree to which employees feel comfortable expressing themselves.
Psychological safety is demonstrated by day-to-day behaviour. How does a leader behave toward a coworker who disagrees with their decision? How does a manager react to a coworker asking an awkward question? Is Feedback allowed only when it confirms current beliefs?
When a leader reacts negatively to a coworker disagreeing with a decision, publicly belittling a coworker, or dismissing legitimate concerns, they send a clear message throughout the company. People soon learn what can safely be said and what must remain unspoken.
Leadership is most effective when leaders can listen without immediately responding as if defending their own views.
Authority secures compliance. Trust facilitates free-flowing communication.
Some confuse psychological safety with never allowing discomfort to occur in the workplace. That is unrealistic and undesirable.
Growth in One's profession is often achieved through challenging roles, criticism, differing viewpoints and expectations.
A workplace that fosters psychological safety can be both high expectation and rigidly performance driven with accountability for unacceptable conduct.
The distinction exists in how processes are implemented.
Criticism can be delivered directly without being demeaning; disagreement can be clearly stated without being personally directed; accountability can exist without fostering an intimidating work place culture.
Expectations for productivity and accountability are not mutually exclusive. They should co-exist.
Psychological safety can’t be created through a policy, a yearly workshop or some leader declaring it.
It develops from repeated behaviours and experiences that provide evidence to employees as to whether their comments and opinions will truly be respected.
For organisations to build psychological safety into their daily operations. Leaders must model an environment of open discussion. When leaders admit to being uncertain and accept criticism; it demonstrates to employees that in order to earn credibility professionally – you don't have to appear perfect.
Employee contributions must be listened to with respect. Listening doesn't necessarily mean agreeing, however when employees’ input is dismissed - future contribution is discouraged.
When mistakes occur, they must be viewed as opportunities for growth. Organisations should assess what went wrong and why, and how to prevent such occurrences in the future while maintaining accountability.
Constructive and consistent feedback must exist throughout an organization. Humiliation via public ridicule, sarcasm and personal attacks - no matter how well-intentioned they might seem in relation to improving performance - severely undermines trust.
Meaningful responses to questions/suggestions must follow. Providing opportunity for employees' ideas and recommendations without reviewing them in detail will breed cynicism. Employees need to believe their concerns are taken seriously.
Psychological safety must be inclusive of all levels within an organisation. An organisation cannot claim an "open" culture when only the upper-level management feels confident enough to express disagreement.
Lastly, psychological safety must be demonstrated consistently, not just spoken of.
Psychological safety must become a part of developing effective leadership skills, enhancing team function and communication practices and organisational accountability.
HR Departments can support the creation of psychological safety in the workplace - but HR Departments alone cannot create psychological safety.
Responsibility extends to all senior leadership, all line managers, and everyone whose behaviour impacts the workplace.
Recognising that psychological safety can't be measured solely by asking employees if they're happy.
There are times when employees will thoroughly enjoy their job, like and respect their coworkers and still fear reporting a problem or concern.
Perhaps more telling is if employees would speak out when there is potential discomfort or unpopularity associated with their comments/opinions.
Each workplace will experience conflicts, errors, pressure and unknowns. Psychological safety does not remove these elements.
However, it does determine how employees react to them.
A workplace in which employees can ask questions, recognise limits, raise concerns, and respectfully disagree is much more capable of adapting, growing and performing at its highest level.
Additionally, a workplace with this type of atmosphere is more likely to view each employee as an individual whose voice matters rather than viewing employees as mere resources required to produce results.
Ultimately, psychological safety isn't about making work easier.
It's about allowing honest conversation.